2008年6月11日 星期三

Yamaha vs Kawai

由於老師要求不可用數碼鋼琴,左計右計,決定在網上找用家放售的二手琴。經一輪的研究找來7個琴作比較。分別如下:



  1. Model:Yamaha U3 ﹝日本制,出廠年份:1962,$14xxx,可彈到演奏級﹞

  2. Model:Yamaha U3 ﹝日本制,出廠年份:1982,$19xxx,可彈到演奏級,琴行放售﹞

  3. Model:Yamaha U-X ﹝日本制,出廠年份:1980,$18xxx,可彈到演奏級﹞

  4. Model:Kawai BL-71 ﹝日本制,出廠年份:1979,$13xxx,可彈到演奏級﹞

  5. Model:Yamaha LX110T  ﹝印尼制,出廠年份:不詳,購自通利,$14xxx,可彈到八級﹞

  6. Model:Kawai BS-10 ﹝出廠年份:1987,$15xxx,可彈到八級﹞

  7. Model:Kawai NS-15 ﹝出廠年份:不詳,$8xxx,可彈到八級﹞

大家有無意見?


4 則留言:

  1. 我唔識鋼琴, 但淨係睇價錢, 第五個可以刪除: 印尼制, 14xxx 只可彈到八級...
    [版主回覆06/11/2008 17:27:00]其實我對1及4最大興趣,並打算今個星期六去試琴。我今天食lunch時去過通利睇,而家個U3琴要$60700,彈落D聲都唔錯,好清脆。因為而家U3咁貴,搞到第1個琴好似好抵咁,不過個琴有成46年歷史好嚇人。加上我肯定唔只係第二手,可能係3、4、5、6、7、8手,怕自己唔識睇,會選擇錯誤。而Kawai既琴聲通常都較甜和柔和,我比較喜歡,加上琴齡年輕好多,好似都係一個不錯的選擇。唉!而家有點十五十六。

    回覆刪除
  2. If you wish to proceed to diplomatic level, according to my teach, U5 from Yamada is the only choice, as the touching is the heaviest among Japanese piano, also it has a special pedal which enable you to play some special effect at the diplomatic level (called 特定延長) - not even many European piano got this pedal.
    Do u remember my piano is the European one - PIEYEL, and I did pay about HK$8000 more on a model with this function.
    Hope these help you too!
    [版主回覆06/12/2008 12:52:00]Thanks for your advise. By the way, I will consider to buy a new and high-end one when I have been qualified to proceed to diplomatic level. At this moment, it will be good enough to spend a cheaper price to have a so called "diplomatic level" piano.

    回覆刪除
  3. Oh yes, then U3 should be ok lah

    回覆刪除
  4. 唔知係咪心理作用我硬係覺得yamaha D聲係好聽D架
    [版主回覆06/13/2008 10:10:00]好唔好聽好主觀既,不過我發覺Yamaha和Kawi都各有支持者。

    回覆刪除